Depressed People Don't Do Anything Much- That Hurts More, Not Helps----

Wed, 11/12/2008 - 6:49AM by justanerd1975 13 Comments - 53 Views

Exercise and Depression
By Dr Greg Mulhauser

How useful is exercise for people with severe depression, anxiety, or chronic mental illness? Hundreds of studies suggest it may help, but the actual causal relationships between exercise and mental health remain unclear. The December issue of the Harvard Mental Health Letter outlines several possible explanations for the apparent mood-enhancing effect of exercise.

It remains difficult to identify the exact causal relationships between mood and exercise, as the press release explains:

It’s also possible that exercise’s effect on mental health is an illusion, says the Harvard Mental Health Letter. According to some surveys and observational studies, it could be that depression and anxiety prevent people from exercising, rather than the other way around. Or some feature of personality or upbringing might cause both depression and sedentary habits.

Even controlled trials on the subject often have problems, such as insufficient follow-up, the difficulty of correcting for the effect of expectations, and the fact that people who volunteer for exercise studies are not necessarily typical.

These doubts may not matter, because exercise has many health benefits and does little harm. But low motivation is a problem. People are often told to find an activity they enjoy, but depressed people don’t enjoy anything much. So it’s necessary to begin slowly and remember that exercise does not have to be strenuous to be helpful. Walking, gardening, or household work will do.


1

Great Article - So true, start with a little bit at a time!!!

Wed, 11/12/2008 - 3:42pm

2

Yes, when I was depressed for a season last Winter-which came out of nowhere and was so dibilitating,btw- I didn't want to shower never mind exercize, but after a few months(it lasted for about 6) I started forcing myself to take daily walks at local parks and trials, at the strong suggestion of a friend- and found that just being out in nature and among other people, even if I couldn't bring myself to have conversation with them, helped me feel a sense of community again, and filled that suddenly empty spot inside that was growing so lonely, at least some. God did take it away eventually, but not before I learned a lot about it and I learned that God will never let go of me, no matter what Eye-wink

"If the lion lies down with the lamb, the lamb must be replaced frequently." --Attributed to Martin Luther In the immediate aftermath of the terrorist violence of September 11, 2001.

Wed, 11/12/2008 - 4:44pm

3

maybe you have the thing -i forget what it is called. but I know i get it when it becomes winter. Seasonal something disorder. You need to have more light in the winter, cause you get depressed because there is not as much natural sunlight at that time of year. I bought a special lamp from amzaon.com. You sit in front of it at night. Helps your mood,. -seasonal affective disorder. (sad)

Wed, 11/12/2008 - 6:32pm

4

Idk angel, I hope I haven't developed that disorder! My Gramm has Seasonal Affect Disorder and she says it is no fun at all. I hope it's not hereditary- I have no idea. Another friend of mine actually mentioned this to me too. I'm trusting God that either He won't let it happen again or if He does, He will stay with me extra close and help me through it, just like last Winter Eye-wink I still hope that I don't have it again, and I will be praying accordingly. Maybe I should look into one of those lamps to use, as a preventative measure just in case- how much are they, angel?

"If the lion lies down with the lamb, the lamb must be replaced frequently." --Attributed to Martin Luther In the immediate aftermath of the terrorist violence of September 11, 2001.

Thu, 11/13/2008 - 11:33am

5

i got mine on amazon. I just did a search on there for one under sad lamps. There is one for 50 dollars, you can get it also on target.com

Thu, 11/13/2008 - 1:13pm

6

After a work injury took my medical career from me I fell into a deep depression. Losing your career is like losing a huge part of yourself. It was like a death.

This article really hit it on the head...when you are depressed you do nothing, wish you felt nothing, and everything seemed to demand more effort than it should. Getting out of it is a struggle that many fight with mixed results.

When I realized that I was looking at years of surgery to repair my arm I went out and adopted a dog. I knew I was going to be spending a lot of time alone while my kids were at school. I had divorced just prior to my injury and the prospect of being home alone was too much for me. Looking back I know it was one of the best things I could ever have done.

Adopting a pet, especially a dog, demands that you take them out to walk them. I had to go out with him everyday. It was not long before I realized that I took him everywhere I went, and that I was going out more than I was sitting at home alone feeling sorry for myself. It was magical how a tiny little teacup poodle changed me.

When my Grandmother died three years later I knew my Mom was struggling with grief. Within the next three months we lost both of my Father's parents too. I went out and got them a dog. Within a year they had adopted two more. I think that having a pet that depends upon you, gives you unconditional love and forces you to go out into the world instead of closing yourself off...is a wonderful thing. My parents were not "dog" people before they got their pets but now they are a source of daily joy for them both.

Anything that helps you get out in the sunshine and look beyond your pain is a fabulous thing. Thanks for sharing this article!

Fri, 11/14/2008 - 1:12pm

7

thanx, angel! I'm gonna ask for one for christmas Eye-wink Lol!
hey, my MIL always wants to buy me something big...and last year I asked for, and got, an electric blanket, lol!... why not a SAD lamp?

I know, Cheeky- it seems that anything we have our identities wrapped up on can give us a little 'death' inside when we lose it, for sure. I know now that my aforementioned 'depression' (whatever it was!) came on the heels of my 'losing' my stepsister S. from my life, just 3 short years after I had found her, she was 'gone'-(we were seperated in the foster-care system when she was a baby, and she had moved in with us just a few years after we reunited and she turned 18,which was doomed to fail...for a lot of reasons...anywho, she lives with her mother and father now again, and she never speaks to me. Hopefully, someday she will see my side of the story, but untill then...?) It is hard to love something so much /feel like you need something so much and feel it slipping through your fingers... all that time investment, the senselessness of a career-ending and life-as-you-knew-it ending injury a heart break? Yeah, I get that Eye-wink
I had to grieve, mourn, be in denial about, be angry about,
cry until I had nothing left but empty wretches about, and finally, accept that a dream of mine since I was 14 years old (when we were first seperated)had died.

Your so right, depression feels like your just this empty flesh-sack(sorry for the image,lol) that has no real human soul in it... bu just keeps on living. And you have to meet all of your life responsibilities numb, not even able to move past the anger and grief that you know are holding you back. It is so, so, very sad. I feel much more now for people who are going through it/have been through it. I found an old friend again by chance during the midst of it, one who happened to be going through it too- and I could chat with her just online, since she now lives in the UK. What a blessing! Just to know that someone else *gets* what your going through, and doesn't judge you. Won't say your crazy, or that you just need to 'get over it'- or worst of all, to have a fellow believer say your disobeying God by feeling so sad. That "He should be your joy." Well, Iv'e got news for people- He is my joy, WAS my joy and always will be, my joy- but He still knows that people, sometimes, just feel really, really, really dam sad. And empty. And scared for what the future will bring. He knew all of my grief, and my anger. He held me with His strong arms and comforted me with His word. He wiped away every tear. Kept them in a bottle, just as Psalm 56:8 says..."You know my waderings, you put my tears in a bottle- are they not in Your book?" I know that He keeps a record of all of our pain, so He can wipe it all away when we see Him face to face in Heaven Eye-wink God never made me feel like I was sinning against Him during that time, He only encouraged me with His never-failing love for me and His perfect peace that only He could give me, and I suggest that people do the same for other people.

Your so right about the pets. I couldn't let anyone in, really in, if you know what I mean, during that time so I would not return friend's calls, wouldn't talk- really talk- to even my husband, and I was on-call with my kids, in robot-mom mode. The only friend I allowed myself was my cat, who I have had since I was 16.
She sat with me, purred when scratched her, and let me feel the life and vitality of her warm body when she lay next to me. She was my link to what living was like. I will be a mess for a minute when she passes away, but I have already put a prayer-covring over that day Eye-wink I know that I will see her in Heaven,too- God says that we will have our beloved family pets again, there in Heaven Eye-wink Yes, I probably should have had a dog to force me to walk with him/her- it would have been even better for me to have that.

Yes, anything that gets you out into the sunshine- a beutiful thing. I remember calling my pastors wife sometime in the midst of the first few months of it and saying that I wouldn't even be getting out of bed if it weren't for having to take care of my kids, I'd just stay in bed all day with the covers pulled up over my head-and her telling me to thank God that I had these children, because they did force me t get out of bed. "See?" she said, "That's God's sovereignty in your life. He knew this would come. It's Ok, He is here with you." Her words really meant a lot to me. I say, a dogz(or even a cat;) and at least one friend who has been there or done that, and calling someone wise for good council.... that's what I learned through my depression. I hope it's worth something, to someone.

"If the lion lies down with the lamb, the lamb must be replaced frequently." --Attributed to Martin Luther In the immediate aftermath of the terrorist violence of September 11, 2001.

Fri, 11/14/2008 - 5:07pm

8

Ohhh. Yeah, I have none about the good affects of exercise in this area for a while. Being active releases a feel good chem. That's why activity is one of the first things that a primary physician should ask about, it has more than just one health benefit. Another thing that is good for some and not all, is Ginkgo Biloba.

Mon, 11/17/2008 - 12:03pm

9

Oh I never heard about Ginko. Hmm, I will have to get some to keep with my SAD lamp to ward off any future reoccurances...hopefully Eye-wink
Thanks for the info, Silver Smiling

"If the lion lies down with the lamb, the lamb must be replaced frequently." --Attributed to Martin Luther In the immediate aftermath of the terrorist violence of September 11, 2001.

Mon, 11/17/2008 - 3:22pm

10

also, vit. b12-just started taking that one myself

Mon, 11/17/2008 - 4:55pm

11

ahhhh B-12, huh? I wonder if there's enough B-12 in my Winsor Pilates daily vitimans? I will have to see...lmao!

"If the lion lies down with the lamb, the lamb must be replaced frequently." --Attributed to Martin Luther In the immediate aftermath of the terrorist violence of September 11, 2001.

Tue, 11/18/2008 - 9:37am

12

suppose to help with depression, etc. google it-vit b 12

Tue, 11/18/2008 - 5:55pm

13

good for energy-b12

Tue, 11/18/2008 - 6:15pm


Post A Comment

To post comments, please log in or register.

About Me